3D Printer World compares 3D printers, supplies, software and free model sites for 2026.

Home / Filament And Resin

Best Engineering Filament Compared: PETG, ABS, ASA and Nylon

Choose the material for the heat, impact, wear or chemical exposure your part must handle. The highest strength figure alone does not decide the best fit.

Top pick

Choose by the part’s demands

Start with the likely failure: heat, movement, impacts, outdoor exposure or deformation under load. The article compares materials by those needs.

As seen in

Recommendations explained in this guide

Open a row’s specs for the complete details.
Best Engineering Filament: comparison and details
MaterialBest forWhat to know
1
PLA
Stiff indoor templates and fixturesReject it when the part’s heat or impact demands exceed the grade’s limits.
PLA details
Best for
Stiff indoor templates and fixtures
What to know
Reject it when the part’s heat or impact demands exceed the grade’s limits.
2
PETG
Housings and lightly loaded bracketsConsider bending and gradual deformation under a lasting load.
PETG details
Best for
Housings and lightly loaded brackets
What to know
Consider bending and gradual deformation under a lasting load.
3
ASA
Outdoor covers and sensor mountsCheck enclosure, bed-temperature and ventilation requirements.
ASA details
Best for
Outdoor covers and sensor mounts
What to know
Check enclosure, bed-temperature and ventilation requirements.
4
Unfilled nylon
Moving parts and flexible latchesAccount for drying and moisture-related changes in fit or stiffness.
Unfilled nylon details
Best for
Moving parts and flexible latches
What to know
Account for drying and moisture-related changes in fit or stiffness.
5
PA612-CF or PA12-CF
Rigid nylon fixturesCheck drying, nozzle wear and whether added stiffness suits the part.
PA612-CF or PA12-CF details
Best for
Rigid nylon fixtures
What to know
Check drying, nozzle wear and whether added stiffness suits the part.
6
PC blend
Warm, mechanically loaded housingsCheck the exact grade’s nozzle, bed and enclosure requirements.
PC blend details
Best for
Warm, mechanically loaded housings
What to know
Check the exact grade’s nozzle, bed and enclosure requirements.

6 materials shown

Compare materials side by side

Choose two materials to compare their full details. Add a third if you need it.

Select two materials to start comparing.

When it comes to the best engineering filament, the first hurdle you encounter after buying a 3D printer is choosing the filament.

When you enter an online store, the names alone (PLA, PLA+, PLA-CF, PETG, PETG-CF, TPU, ABS, ASA, PC, PA, PVA…) are overwhelming. Not knowing what to buy, you end up putting the cheapest PLA into your cart first.

You must select a material suitable for the intended purpose.

For example, when making ornaments, there is no need to specifically use nylon. If you make parts out of PLA for use inside a car in the middle of summer, they may deform due to the heat.

For many users, both PA-CF and PC-CF appear to be "high-strength materials," but in practical applications, one is better suited to withstand long-term mechanical loads and frictional wear, while the other excels in high-temperature environments and dimensional stability. Therefore, it is necessary to understand the characteristics of each material before making a selection.

Compare Materials Side by Side

Material · Recommended uses · Difficulty · Nozzle temperature starting range · Bed starting range · Drying importance

PLA · Beginners, models, general prototypes · ★ · 200-230℃ · 45-60℃ · Medium

PETG · Household goods and functional parts · ★★ · 230-260℃ · 60-80℃ · High

ABS · Machine parts and heat-resistant parts · ★★★ · 240-270℃ · 80-100℃ · Medium

ASA · Outdoor, automotive, heat-resistant parts · ★★★ · 240-270℃ · 80-100℃ · Medium

TPU · Flexible parts · ★★★ · 210-240℃ · 35-60℃ · High

PA/Nylon · Machine parts, high strength · ★★★★ · 250-290℃ · 70-100℃ · Very high

PC · High-strength, heat-resistant parts · ★★★★ · 250-300℃ · 90-110℃ · Very high

The values above are general starting points. Actual values may vary depending on the filament brand and grade.

Filament · Strength (tensile strength) · Durability (impact resistance) · Heat resistance (HDT) · Wear resistance (friction resistance)

PLA · 7 / 10 · 4 / 10 · 3 / 10 · 3 / 10

ABS · 7 / 10 · 6 / 10 · 6 / 10 · 5 / 10

PETG · 8 / 10 · 7 / 10 · 6 / 10 · 6 / 10

TPU · 4 / 10 · 9 / 10 · 4 / 10 · 6 / 10

Nylon · 9 / 10 · 9 / 10 · 7 / 10 · 9 / 10

PC · 10 / 10 · 9 / 10 · 9 / 10 · 7 / 10

ASA · 7 / 10 · 6 / 10 · 7 / 10 · 6 / 10

Carbon PLA · 9 / 10 · 5 / 10 · 4 / 10 · 7 / 10

Carbon PETG · 9 / 10 · 6 / 10 · 6 / 10 · 8 / 10

Carbon Nylon · 10 / 10 · 8 / 10 · 7 / 10 · 10 / 10

Criteria: The higher the "hardness," the less deformation and the lower the flexibility.

Filament · Hardness (based on rigidity / Shore hardness) · Description

PC (Polycarbonate) · Very hard (high rigidity) · Good for industrial and structural applications

Carbon Nylon · Very hard (reinforced fiber) · Excellent for high-strength, lightweight parts

Carbon PLA · Hard (stronger than basic PLA) · Strong resistance to external deformation

PLA · Hard (but brittle) · High rigidity but brittle

PETG · Medium (slightly flexible) · A balance of practicality and flexibility

ABS · Medium (slightly flexible) · Suitable for shock absorption

ASA · Medium · Similar to ABS but with added UV resistance

Nylon · Flexible (bends easily) · Very strong but not hard

TPU · Very flexible (soft as rubber) · Lowest hardness

Match the Filament to What Your Part Needs to Do

In industrial applications, component failure is often not due to excessive one-time load, but rather to long-term effects of vibration, friction, impact, or cyclic stress.

It looks complicated, but it can be summarized in three questions.

What will be made? Is it an object to look at and enjoy, a component that actually bears weight, or an object to be placed outdoors?

How much difficulty is acceptable? Is it a situation where you can just print again if you fail, or is it a situation where you must succeed on the first try?

Can my equipment handle the nozzle material, chamber structure, and maximum temperature?

It is best to determine the usage environment first and then select the filament.

  • First print, decoration: PLA
  • Durable Lifestyle Parts: PETG
  • Parts exposed to heat and sunlight: ASA or ABS (requires a sealed printer)
  • Part that needs to bend: TPU
  • Gears and structural parts: Nylon or PC (must dry)

If you are a beginner, follow this order:

PLA → PETG → TPU → ABS/ASA → Engineering Material

Move up one step at a time. If you go straight to ABS without getting a feel for printing with PLA, you will not be able to distinguish whether the cause of a failure is the settings, the material, or the equipment.

PLA and PETG for Everyday Functional Parts

PLA is sufficient for 80% of all prints.

There is almost no shrinkage, so even large items come out well.

Use for figures, models, prototypes, storage accessories, educational materials, merchandise, and indoor stands.

In particular, PLA alone is often sufficient for prototypes used for dimensional verification or product design mockups. If you want a PLA+ spool for that kind of work, see my Inland PLA+ review.

The biggest weakness is heat resistance.

In the Bambu Lab filament guide, the heat deflection temperature (HDT) of standard PLA is approximately 57°C.

Therefore, it may not be suitable for parts placed inside a car or near hot equipment during the summer.

It breaks easily upon impact. It is not tough and tends to snap cleanly.

If you have ever had an item made of PLA break due to heat or impact, the next best thing is PETG.

It is tougher than PLA. It bends instead of breaking easily.

In Bambu Lab's recent filament guide, the PETG series is also shown to have higher impact strength than PLA and an HDT of approximately 69°C.

It is resistant to moisture and chemicals.

Use for: kitchen and bathroom accessories, flower pots, outdoor stands, tool holders, functional parts, and items that come into contact with water.

Green 3D-printed wavy soap dish holding a wet bar of white soap, the kind of part that stays in contact with water

Strings (spiderwebs) form easily. You may need to adjust the retraction settings.

It adheres too strongly to smooth PEI plates, so the coating may peel off when you remove the print. Apply a thin layer of release agent or use a textured plate.

It absorbs moisture easily.

Example PETG settings

  • Nozzle: 230-260℃
  • Bed: 60-80℃
  • Cooling: Start lower than PLA
  • Drying: Highly recommended

ABS and ASA for Parts Exposed to Heat or Weather

ABS is a high-strength thermoplastic widely used in Lego blocks, automotive parts, and home appliance exteriors due to its strong and rigid properties.

It has higher heat resistance than PLA and is relatively strong against impact.

In the Bambu Lab guide, the HDT of standard ABS is given as approximately 87°C.

Post-processing such as drilling, sanding, and painting is relatively easy after printing. Smoothing using acetone is also possible to create a smooth surface.

It is used in applications requiring strong physical properties, such as machine parts, housings, tool handles, and automotive prototypes.

Five 3D-printed functional parts, including pipe connectors, a broom connector and a desk-mount headphone holder

When printing ABS with an open-type printer, it shrinks as it cools, causing the edges to lift and the layers to crack. This problem is resolved if a sealed chamber maintains the temperature.

To prevent the print from coming off, it is recommended to use PVA adhesive (glue stick) or ABS bed adhesive.

Example ABS settings

  • Nozzle: 240-270℃
  • Bed: 80-100℃
  • Cooling: Low
  • Chamber: Keep it reliably warm
  • Brim: Use it actively on large parts

Fumes and Ventilation

Safety is the most important consideration when printing with ABS filament. When heated, ABS emits volatile organic compounds (VOCs), particularly styrene gas and ultrafine particles (UFP). Since styrene is toxic and can be classified as a potential carcinogen, special caution is required.

Thorough ventilation is essential. Printing ABS in a confined space is extremely dangerous. During printing, you must open windows and operate a ventilation fan to ensure sufficient indoor air circulation.

Filter Inspection and Replacement: The carbon filter installed in the printer must be checked periodically, and replaced immediately when it becomes saturated. If the filter's performance deteriorates, its effectiveness in removing harmful substances also decreases.

If the printing space can be separated, it is ideal to operate the ABS printer in a separate workspace isolated from sleeping or living areas.

Do not open the door immediately after printing; wait a few minutes and then open it while ventilating.

When ASA Is the Better Choice

ABS and ASA (Acrylonitrile Styrene Acrylate) are filaments that are frequently compared due to their very similar properties. In fact, ASA can be viewed as a material developed to compensate for the shortcomings of ABS.

Property · ABS (Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene) · ASA (Acrylonitrile Styrene Acrylate)

Strengths · Excellent rigidity, durability, heat resistance, and processability · Improved UV resistance, weather resistance, and impact resistance

Weaknesses · Severe warping; strong odor and harmful vapors generated during printing · Odors and harmful vapors generated during printing; higher price than ABS

UV resistance · Relatively weak, discoloration and weakening with prolonged exposure to UV rays · Relatively strong, suitable for outdoor use

Surface finish · Matte or slight gloss. Acetone smoothing possible. · Relatively good aesthetic quality, fewer layer lines

Best uses · Indoor functional parts, prototypes, heat-resistant parts · Outdoor parts (automotive, signage, etc.), parts for UV exposure environments

The HDT of Bambu Lab's official ASA is approximately 100°C, the recommended nozzle temperature is 240-270°C, and the bed temperature is 80-100°C.

PETG, ABS and ASA test prints at 26°C and at 100°C, where the PETG base warps while ABS and ASA hold their shape

In environments exposed to sunlight for extended periods, ASA is often more suitable than ABS.

  • Outdoor sensor case
  • Drone parts
  • Automotive exterior parts
  • Outdoor equipment parts
  • Brackets exposed to sunlight
  • Outdoor signs
Black 3D-printed mailbox with a red flag and nameplate, mounted on a post outdoors as an example of an outdoor part

Print speed: 250 mm/s or less recommended

Drying: 80℃, 8 hours if necessary

In addition, since warping is prone to occur with large parts, we advise using a sealed printer, high bed temperature, and low print speed.

If you frequently print ASA at school, in the office, or at home, it is recommended to provide ventilation or a separate printing space.

Nylon for Parts That Move or Take Impacts

PA stands for Polyamide.

It is a material commonly called nylon.

It has good strength and toughness, making it suitable for use in actual machine parts.

Nylon: It possesses excellent tensile strength and abrasion resistance. It is much stronger and more flexible than standard PLA or PETG, making it highly resistant to impact.

Nylon is used in parts subjected to friction and load, such as gears and hinges.

Black 3D-printed hinge screwed between two wooden boards, a moving part that takes friction and load

The greatest enemy of nylon is moisture.

Nylon absorbs moisture very easily.

Even in Bambu Lab's current guide, the PA series, such as PA6-CF, is classified as requiring drying before printing, and the saturated water absorption rate of some PA grades is given as over 2%.

When the filament gets wet, bubbles, stringing, surface defects, reduced strength, and dimensional instability may occur.

Print quality deteriorates after being exposed to the air for just a few hours. You must use the product immediately after taking it out of the dryer, or use it with a drying function enabled.

Example nylon settings

  • Nozzle: 250-290℃
  • Bed: 70-100℃
  • Drying: Consider it almost essential
  • Storage: Airtight + Desiccant
  • Chamber: Keep warm depending on the material

Carbon Fiber Nylon (PA-CF)

PA-CF is short for Polyamide Carbon Fiber. It uses nylon as a base resin and adds carbon fibers to improve the material's strength, stiffness, and dimensional stability.

Nylon itself has good toughness and wear resistance, but it is prone to shrinkage and warping during the printing process. Adding carbon fiber significantly improves these problems and further enhances the material's mechanical properties.

Taking eSUN PA-CF as an example, this material is developed based on the nylon 6/66 copolymer system and reinforced with approximately 20% carbon fiber. Compared to ordinary nylon materials, its strength, rigidity, and impact resistance are improved, while maintaining the good wear resistance of nylon materials.

For example, in automated production lines, many fixtures, positioning components, and auxiliary structural parts undergo a large number of repetitive movements every day. If the material is too rigid, it may crack after long-term stress; PA-CF can absorb some stress while maintaining structural strength, making it more suitable for such applications.

Black eSUN PA-CF printed fixture with a matte surface, the kind of part used on automated production lines

This eSUN PA-CF is an engineering-grade material developed based on this need. In addition to high strength and rigidity, it has a heat distortion temperature of approximately 155°C and a low shrinkage rate. During printing, it is less prone to significant warping and cracking, and the finished product exhibits a delicate matte texture.

In industrial manufacturing, it is frequently used to produce tooling fixtures, machine supports, and robot structural components. Due to its good wear resistance, it is also commonly used in moving parts such as gears and guide rail assemblies.

At the same time, some small structural components that were originally made of metal are beginning to be replaced with eSUN PA-CF. This can reduce weight and shorten production cycles, improving the efficiency of customized production.

Three twisted eSUN PA-CF printed pieces stacked on each other, showing the fine matte texture of the material

Check Whether Polycarbonate Fits Your Part and Printer

PC stands for polycarbonate.

It is used in fields requiring high strength and heat resistance.

Excellent heat resistance and impact strength

  • Machine parts
  • High-temperature environment components
  • Protective covers
  • Structural parts
  • Parts requiring high impact strength

However, PC is not a material for beginners.

With PC, high nozzle temperature, high bed temperature, moisture management, and warping management are all important.

Printing is very difficult (requires a dedicated hot end/chamber)

Check the maximum nozzle temperature. High-temperature engineering materials must fall within the equipment's maximum nozzle temperature specifications. This is a point that needs to be verified before purchasing.

Default starting range

  • Nozzle: 250-300℃
  • Bed: 90-110℃
  • Drying: Very important
  • Chamber: Advantageous for a stable high-temperature environment

Carbon Fiber Polycarbonate (PC-CF)

PC-CF is a carbon fiber reinforced polycarbonate material.

Polycarbonate is a high-performance engineering plastic with excellent heat resistance and dimensional stability. The addition of carbon fiber further enhances the material's rigidity, allowing it to maintain good structural strength even at high temperatures.

Compared to PA-CF, PC-CF places greater emphasis on structural stability rather than toughness.

If the application environment prioritizes abrasion resistance, impact resistance, and long-term mechanical reliability, then PA-CF is usually a more suitable choice.

If the parts need to be in a high-temperature environment for a long time and have high requirements for dimensional stability, then PC-CF may be more advantageous.

Decide Whether Carbon or Glass Fibers Help Your Part

These include PLA-CF, PETG-CF, PA-CF, ASA-GF, etc. They are materials in which fibers are mixed with a base resin to enhance rigidity and dimensional stability.

Bambu Lab ABS-GF is a filament that significantly enhances mechanical properties by blending glass fibers into standard ABS. It offers superior strength, stiffness, temperature resistance, and dimensional stability compared to standard ABS, and is less susceptible to warping.

Strips printed in ABS and ABS-GF side by side, the plain ABS edge lifting from warping while the ABS-GF strip stays flat

PLA-CF makes it easier to produce results that appear to have a surface closer to matte and higher rigidity than regular PLA.

The surface has a matte texture. Many people like this.

If you run these through a brass nozzle, the hole gets bigger in just tens of hours.

This is not a malfunction, but wear. The fibers grind down the inner walls of the nozzle. The dimensions of the printed object gradually increase, and the surface becomes messy. If you plan to use carbon fiber, please budget for a hardened steel nozzle when making your purchase.

And for fiber-filled filaments, a nozzle of 0.4mm or larger is generally more suitable than a 0.2mm nozzle, which is too small.

If you want to reduce the risk of clogging, 0.6mm can also be a good choice.

Dust caution: Carbon dust is harmful to health. Wear a mask during post-processing (sanding).

Consider Other Filaments for Unusual Demands

TPU for Flexible Parts

TPU is a flexible material like rubber.

You can make parts that are not completely rubber but bend or restore when pressed by hand.

Applications: Useful for parts requiring shock absorption or flexibility, such as bumpers, tire inserts, body guards, and mounts.

It is classified by hardness (Shore hardness). 95A is about the hardness of a shoe sole, while 85A is softer. The lower the number, the softer it is and the more difficult it is to work with.

Please make sure to lower the speed. If you push too fast, the filament stretches and the extrusion does not work properly.

PVA Supports

It is a water-soluble support material.

It eliminates the risk of losing details while using cutters to remove supports from sculptures with complex shapes or many undercuts.

However, it is very expensive and extremely susceptible to moisture. Please use it only when absolutely necessary and store it thoroughly.

Dry and Store Engineering Filament

Moisture-soaked filament is the number one cause of print failure.

  • Clicking and popping sounds during printing
  • The surface is rough and dirty
  • The extrusion volume is inconsistent
  • In severe cases, the nozzle gets clogged

Moisture absorption ranking: Nylon > TPU > PETG > ABS/ASA > PLA. Storage method: airtight container + desiccant.

If the spool has been left unused for a long time, please cut off about 1 meter of the beginning before using it.

Please watch the drying temperature. If it is too high, the filaments will stick together, rendering the entire spool unusable.

Check the Printed Part Before You Rely On It

In fact, durability can be divided into various categories based on different aspects such as chemical resistance, heat resistance, and impact resistance, but this time, focusing more on interlayer adhesion, with the same structure and print conditions, we conducted strength tests on PLA, ABS, PETG, and PA-CF materials.

We measured this structure by hanging it on a scale and applying a load while pulling it.

Since the scale is fixed, the force is displayed on the scale when the structure is pulled downwards.

By doing this, you can check the maximum force the structure can withstand.

3D model of the pull-test piece, a rectangular block with a ring handle on top, used to compare filament strength

Although it is not measured using perfect experimental equipment, I think this is a sufficient method for simply comparing strength differences between materials.

PLA is the easiest material to print, but it is weak against impact or repetitive loads.

In actual tests, failure occurred under a load of approximately 1.2 kg.

It feels solid in the hand, but due to the inherent brittleness of PLA (the tendency to break suddenly), we confirmed that it breaks immediately when a certain load is exceeded.

ABS is a material that is more impact-resistant than PLA.

The test results showed that it could withstand a load of approximately 2.9 kg.

Rather than breaking immediately like PLA, it exhibited a characteristic of holding on slightly more flexibly before breaking.

PETG is a material with characteristics intermediate between PLA and ABS.

In this test, it appeared to withstand a load of approximately 4.16 kg.

It demonstrated that it is much stronger than PLA and can withstand slightly higher loads than ABS.

In particular, during the test, we observed that the ring part deformed slightly while supporting the load before breaking.

PA-CF is a composite material containing carbon fiber in nylon, characterized by high rigidity.

In actual tests, it demonstrated the highest strength, withstanding a load of approximately 5 kg.

Also, compared to PETG, it showed less noticeable deformation and appeared to support the load while maintaining its shape relatively well.

However, the material itself is very expensive, and since it contains carbon fiber fragments, it is printed with a 0.6mm nozzle, so fine details can be difficult to bring out.

To briefly summarize the order of strength:

It would be PLA < ABS < PETG < PA-CF.

I believe that even though there may be some margin of error in the load capacity due to it being a simple test, a comparison could still be made to some extent.

As such, in 3D printing, even for the same model, the results vary significantly depending on the material selected.

Conversely, even with the same material, there are aspects where the results can vary significantly depending on the model's structure.

Anisotropy and Strength: Since 3D printed parts are built layer by layer, strength along the Z-axis (layering direction) may be weakened. For parts subjected to strong impact, the printing direction must be carefully determined by considering the direction of the load.

Inexpensive filaments often have inconsistent diameters. If the diameter fluctuates between 1.70 and 1.80 mm when it should be 1.75 mm, the extrusion volume constantly changes. The cause of print failure is the filament, not the equipment, more often than expected.

If you choose based solely on price, the cost of failed prints will exceed the cost of materials.

← All 62 lists